Saturday 17 June 2006

Abolish full-fee places…and raise HECS

Universities need money. To be world-class, as the University of Melbourne aspires to be, requires lots of money. And government is steadily decreasing the amount of money it supplies. That means, inevitably, this shortfall will have to be filled, at least in part, by the students who attend.

I see nothing particularly evil about this. Why should education be free, or even cheap? Education sets you up in life: most courses more or less guarantee you a relatively prosperous career path. And the fact that in Australia, students are not charged while they are studying and hence impoverished, but take on a no-interest loan until they are earning enough to pay it back, sweetens the deal further.

But it’s simply wrong to lower academic standards to get money, as is the current situation. Students, international and domestic, with lots of up-front cash, can get into uni with lower qualifications than those with more smarts but less money.

I say, all remaining hold-outs should reach the conclusion that the basic formula, of students having to pay their university more money to ensure its quality, is the only realistic one. But instead of a double-standard of entry to unis, a more equitable solution is to progressively phase out full-fee places, while significantly raising HECS fees - doubling or tripling them, probably - to make up the shortfall.

3 comments:

boy_fromOz said...

Because high school completes the generalist education you need to get by in society. At university you specialise, with the goal of earning an above-average salary or greater career satisfaction. The state shouldn't be expected to underwrite that lifestyle choice, though there are many other good arguments for subsidising universities.

DCB said...

Well since educated people contribute to our society and make our country a better place...shouldn't the federal govt simply increase their funding to tertiary institutions? In particular taking in mind that the Federal Govt had reduced university funding by some crazy percentage like 20% over the past 10 years. (Don't quote me on the stat but it has definitely been greatly reduced).

There was some interesting discussion about this on a Four Corners program about 6 months ago.

boy_fromOz said...

While every other country is boosting tertiary-ed spending... Knowledge is power in the information age.